Very Good Liner. Goes on easily and stays put. Nice dark black color.

I really liked this eyeliner. Other than it being too expensive, the eyeliner is good

Excellent MAC eyeliner. Love it. A bit pricey thought.

I love this eye liner from MAC. It's very good.  The only thing is that it's a little expensive for my taste.

Terrible liner! I found that it was not creamy enough and did not glide well on my upper lid. It was also very irritating in my eye. I've used much cheaper products that had better results. I would stay away from these! 

I love this eye pencil. It glides on very easily. It gives me that smokey eye look. VERY SEXY. Kim Kardashian gave a review on it in her tutorial so I went and gave it a try. I wear it everyday (i'm such a diva). The only problem is having to reapply on the lower lids

this is the best value ever!! I bought it for about $4.50 so i expected flaking and fading but it lasted 8 hrs on a hot day, no flaking no fading not even a smudge! its now my HG gel liner and i highly recommend it to all of you:D

Fantastic product, very dramatic and easy to use.

This is the only eyeliner besides Estee Lauder's kohl smudging eyeliner that I've bought over and over again throughout the years. While it does smudge on the inner corner of my eye, it does last all day. I have oily eyelids so that may have something to do with it. It's really creamy in consistency so it glides on really well and doesn't tug at the eye.  It's really really black which is what I wanted. I don't like it when an eyeliners says it's black and then it comes out greyish.  You can typically get this bogo at some drugstore anywhere so it's really a good buy. I can never find the black ones in stock so when I do, I buy a couple.

I bought the black liner as a fill in until my next MAC order to replenish my fluidline with little expectations.  I was not expecting this liner to stack up to my blacktrack fliudline at all- I had bought the eggplant one a while back and was not too thrilled with it.  Nevertheless, I took a chance and bought it.  I have to say, I am impressed.  It has great staying power, goes on smooth and hasn't smeared, faded or flaked yet.  I am glad I listened to the advice given on these from all of the wonderful ladies on MUT!  

This is my holy grail eyeliner. I have no idea what I used before it. There's no tugging on my eyelid, the colour payoff is excellent, and you cannot beat the price. 

mac liquid eyeliner is the best eyeliner i have EVER tried.. i have tried so many . . from drugstore brands to high end ones.. i recently tried using clinique liquid eye liner and dont like it as much .. mac eyeliner just glides all in one stroke i love it .

This was my first liquid eyeliner. It is AWFUL. It says that it's waterproof, but it is NOT. Smudges right after you apply. 

 

The wand is awful, too. It's a felt tip, so it starts to splinter after several uses. A brush is better.

this is a pretty good product to use. it's expensive for a drugstore brand but sometimes you can purchase these when they are BOGO at drugstores. the cream liner begins to dry out if you do not tighten it properly.. i love it. great color payoff and staying power

I use this pencil a lot. It goes on creamy, and is nicely pigmented. It is a pain to sharpen, so you'll need to get it cold to sharpen it. It doesn't last all day, but it lasts for many hours before fading(even on my waterline). It can smudge, but I onę noticed product on my hand and not my face. I would buy these again if they were on sale.

This is not as dark as I would expect a dark brown to be. It sort of between dark and medium. It's also slightly bronze. That surprised me, since the color name didn't hint that there would be any shimmer. The pencil is a bit of a pain to sharpen, because the liner is creamy. Which is really nice for applying, but it gets stuck in my sharpener. I have to get the pencil cold to sharpen it. Other than that I have no complaints. It doesn't last all day, but it does last for many hours before fading begins. It's not smudge proof, so be careful. I have accidentally smudged it, though it wasn't noticeable on my face. I happend to notice some liner on my hand was all. I would buy these again if they were on sale.

Everybody note that the pic below is not of the Maybelline Lineworks liner, but of their regular liquid liner. The lineworks liner has a felt tip brush and is pretty easy to hold. It gives a continuous waterproof coverage for about 8 hours. It is still pretty good after that, but I noticed it starts to flake a bit after that, so you'll probably need a touch up.

 

Urban Decay Liquidliner Eyeliner in the shade Chains!

 

From the UD Liquid Liner Eye Liner Packaging

Versatile, Liquid eyeliner that dries sleek and shiny. The tiny brush effortlessly creates Razor-Sharp lines. But if you prefer soft & pretty, smudge a little on lids for long-lasting eye color. Enhances eyes whether worn with eyeshadow or all alone- Urban Decay Liquid Liner

 

Beauty Review By Christina Hanley

 

Urban Decay Liquid Liner in Chains
It's time to break out of boring--and Urban Decay's Liquid Liner in Chains is just the way to do it. This formula is easy to apply due to the long, think brush applicator. Chains is a shimmery green with chrome shine. It is a truly gorgeous shade. I like this worn alone with tons of black mascara or used with Hard Candy's Eye Shadow Quarter in Drama Queen--the green and purple shades of shadow are a wonderful complement to this amazing color.

 

This is actually a decent  liquid liner, it's cheap and long lasting. It did unfortuanately have some flaws though. The reason why I wouldn't buy it again is because of the the brush. I prefer a pen style liner, and this was a thicker brush, making it hard to make tiny lines. It did last a bit and I wore it when I went dancing. It also flakes a tad bit. I didn't notice any stinging feeling like the others wrote.

I'm glad I converted to Gel liner! The product itself is great, many other dupes available and I believe MAC is on the top of the list. 

Not the darkest of black I've seen but it goes on easily.